Why do we take the holidays so seriously? And since when did being grateful become another thing we're supposed to be good at?
In Part One of this two-part Thanksgiving special, Josh brings his Canadian perspective to America's obsession with the holidays, questioning the commercialization of Thanksgiving, Christmas, and everything in between.
Thanksgiving, Gratitude & Finding My People: Why I'm Not Taking the Holidays So Seriously
Are we doing Thanksgiving all wrong? Or have we just turned something relatively simple into another exhausting holiday production?
Every November, Americans collectively lose their minds over Thanksgiving. There are enormous grocery bills, elaborate dinner plans, cross-country flights, family obligations, and enough pumpkin-flavored products to make you question whether we've completely lost control of the situation.
And don't even get me started on Black Friday.
As a Canadian who's spent much of my adult life living in California, I have a slightly different perspective on this entire production. Because growing up in Toronto, Thanksgiving was important, but it never felt quite as enormous as it does in the United States.
And over the years, I've realized something: I don't think we need to take the holidays quite so seriously to appreciate them.
In fact, I've found that the less pressure I put on gratitude, traditions, and creating some imaginary perfect life, the more meaningful those experiences actually become.
So let's talk about Thanksgiving, why I refuse to participate in the annual outrage over commercialized holidays, what psychology tells us about gratitude, and how moving to Los Angeles in my early twenties helped me discover something I didn't even realize I was looking for.
My people.
Canadian Thanksgiving vs. American Thanksgiving: What's the Difference?
First, for anyone who doesn't know, Canadians celebrate Thanksgiving in October, on the second Monday of the month. Americans celebrate on the fourth Thursday of November.
And personally, I've always appreciated the Canadian timing.
It's actually fall. The leaves are changing, the weather is cooling down, and you can enjoy a lovely autumn dinner without immediately being assaulted by Christmas decorations and Mariah Carey.
In Canada, at least from my experience growing up, Thanksgiving was pretty straightforward. You got together with family, ate a ridiculous amount of food, enjoyed the long weekend, and returned to your regularly scheduled programming.
Of course, that doesn't mean all Canadians celebrate the same way, but the holiday generally has a more relaxed cultural presence.
American Thanksgiving, on the other hand, seems to consume the entire country.
There's football, parades, traveling, cooking, shopping, and an overwhelming expectation that everyone should be creating beautiful memories around a perfectly decorated table.
And there are legitimate historical differences between Canadian and American Thanksgiving, although neither country has a particularly spotless history when it comes to European colonization and Indigenous peoples.
Growing up in Canada, I remember being taught some of that history, although looking back, much of it was still presented in a rather sanitized way.
And I think it's important that we recognize those uncomfortable parts of history without pretending a modern holiday celebration needs to become an elaborate performance of guilt.
We can acknowledge historical injustice while choosing to make the day meaningful in our own lives.
Because ultimately, the most valuable part of Thanksgiving might have very little to do with the holiday itself.
Can We Stop Being So Angry About Commercialized Holidays?
There's something that happens every time a holiday approaches that I find endlessly entertaining.
Someone inevitably announces that the entire occasion is manufactured, corporations are manipulating us, and everyone participating is apparently an idiot.
Valentine's Day? Invented to sell flowers.
Halloween? A massive candy marketing scheme.
Christmas? Capitalism wearing a Santa hat.
Thanksgiving? Grocery stores convincing us we need seventeen side dishes and a turkey large enough to feed the entire cast of RuPaul's Drag Race.
And listen, they're not entirely wrong.
We've absolutely commercialized the hell out of these holidays.
But here's my question: Why does that mean we can't enjoy them?
I love having an excuse to celebrate something. I love decorating, creating traditions, getting together with friends, and making life a little more interesting.
Nobody is forcing me to buy matching Thanksgiving napkins or spend hundreds of dollars on holiday decorations. Those are choices.
And I think sometimes we get so caught up in criticizing the commercialization of holidays that we forget we can simply decide what they mean to us.
You can celebrate Valentine's Day without spending money on an expensive dinner.
You can enjoy Christmas without putting yourself into debt.
You can love Halloween without purchasing a twelve-foot skeleton.
Although, let's not get carried away. I do appreciate an outrageously large Halloween decoration.
And you can celebrate Thanksgiving without pretending your family belongs in a Hallmark movie.
Maybe the holidays are simply opportunities to pause, connect with people, and appreciate what we have.
What's so terrible about that?
Gratitude Without the Inspirational Nonsense
Now, let's talk about gratitude.
Because somewhere along the way, being thankful became another thing we're apparently supposed to master.
Wake up at five in the morning. Meditate. Journal. Manifest abundance. Write down seventeen affirmations. Drink something green.
Congratulations, you're now spiritually superior to everyone else.
I'm exaggerating, obviously, but I think the self-help industry has made certain wellness practices feel unnecessarily complicated.
And gratitude is a perfect example.
As I've gotten older, I've become much more interested in how my mindset influences my everyday experiences. Not because I believe positive thinking magically fixes everything, but because I've noticed how easily I can become consumed by what isn't going according to plan.
Between working in fitness, marketing, creating HOT AIR, writing, and navigating everyday life, I'm pretty much always working toward something.
Another project. Another deadline. Another goal.
And while ambition is something I value, I've also realized that constantly focusing on the next thing can make it difficult to appreciate what's happening right now.
That's where practicing gratitude has become useful for me.
Sometimes it's taking a moment to recognize something positive that happened during the day. Sometimes it's thinking about the people I'm thankful for. Sometimes it's writing a few things down.
Nothing particularly elaborate.
No crystal collection required.
The point isn't to create another obligation. It's to remind myself that even when life feels stressful or imperfect, there are often meaningful things happening that deserve my attention.
What Psychology Actually Says About Practicing Gratitude
Here's where things get interesting because gratitude isn't just an inspirational concept.
There's actual psychological research behind it.
Psychologists Robert Emmons and Michael McCullough conducted influential research investigating how regularly reflecting on things we're grateful for affects emotional well-being.
Their findings suggested that deliberately focusing on gratitude could improve certain aspects of well-being, including positive emotions, compared with focusing on everyday frustrations.
You can read their research in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
And what I find particularly interesting is that gratitude doesn't necessarily change your circumstances.
It changes what you're noticing about those circumstances.
Think about how frequently you can have a perfectly wonderful day, receive several compliments, accomplish something meaningful, and then become completely obsessed with one mildly unpleasant interaction.
Somebody sends you an email with a slightly questionable tone, and suddenly you're mentally reconstructing the entire conversation like a detective investigating a homicide.
Meanwhile, you've forgotten everything else that went right.
Psychologists often discuss this through the concept of negativity bias, our tendency to give certain negative experiences more attention than positive ones.
Gratitude can help counterbalance that tendency by encouraging us to recognize experiences we might otherwise overlook.
That doesn't mean ignoring problems.
It means acknowledging that the problems aren't necessarily the entire story.
Being Grateful Doesn't Mean Pretending Life Is Perfect
I want to make something clear because there's a version of gratitude floating around the internet that I genuinely cannot stand.
The idea that if you're unhappy, struggling, or frustrated, you're simply not being grateful enough.
Absolutely not.
Sometimes life is difficult. Sometimes people disappoint us. Sometimes relationships change, opportunities disappear, and things happen that are completely outside our control.
You don't need to thank the universe for every painful experience because apparently it's helping you grow.
Sometimes something just sucks.
And you're allowed to acknowledge that.
For me, gratitude is much more useful when I allow difficult emotions and positive experiences to coexist.
I can be frustrated about something happening professionally while appreciating the opportunities I've already had.
I can feel disappointed about how a relationship has changed while being thankful for the people who continue to show up for me.
I can have enormous goals for my future while recognizing that the life I've already built contains things I once dreamed about.
Gratitude shouldn't make us feel guilty for wanting more. It should help us appreciate what we already have while we continue growing.
And that perspective has become especially meaningful when I think about the people in my life.
Moving From Toronto to Los Angeles Changed More Than My Address
I moved from Canada to California in my early twenties, and when I look back at that decision now, it's interesting how much it changed my life beyond the obvious things.
At the time, I was thinking about opportunities, creativity, building a career, and experiencing something different.
I wasn't necessarily thinking about the emotional reality of moving thousands of miles away from the people and places I'd always known.
Because when you move somewhere new, you're not simply finding an apartment and figuring out where to buy groceries.
You're building an entirely new life.
And part of that process involves creating relationships.
When you grow up somewhere, there's a familiarity that comes with having people around who've known you for years. They understand your history and the environment you came from.
When you move away, that familiarity disappears.
Suddenly, you have to meet new people, create your own community, and figure out where you fit into an entirely different world.
And honestly, I think that's something we underestimate when we talk about moving to a new city.
We focus on the excitement of starting over without always considering the loneliness that can accompany it.
But one of the most meaningful things that happened after moving to Los Angeles was developing friendships that eventually became incredibly important parts of my life.
How I Found My People in California
When I think about the friendships I've built over the years, one thing that stands out is how naturally many of them developed.
Through work, creative projects, shared interests, fitness, and different communities, I met people who understood certain aspects of my life in ways I hadn't necessarily experienced before.
And those connections weren't based on having known one another since childhood.
They were based on the people we were becoming as adults.
We shared experiences, supported one another, celebrated accomplishments, and gradually built meaningful relationships.
Some people became friends. Others became something that felt much more like family.
And I didn't necessarily recognize that transformation as it was happening.
There wasn't some dramatic moment where everyone gathered together and officially announced that we'd become one another's chosen family.
There was no certificate. No committee approval. No ceremonial sash.
Although, honestly, I wouldn't have objected to a sash.
It was the accumulation of everyday experiences that made those relationships meaningful.
And I think that's something important to remember if you're struggling to find your people.
Meaningful friendships rarely appear fully formed.
They develop through time, shared experiences, vulnerability, and the willingness to invest in one another.
The mental health publication Wondermind explores how intentionally nurturing friendships and recognizing shared values can help people develop deeper connections.
And I think that reflects much of what I've experienced.
Finding your people isn't always about searching for the perfect group of friends.
Sometimes it's about recognizing the connections developing around you and allowing those relationships to grow.
The People Who Make Life Feel Like Home
Something else I've learned is that friendships don't necessarily become meaningful simply because you've known someone for a long time.
Time creates history, but emotional connection requires something more.
It requires trust, communication, mutual respect, and the ability to be yourself without constantly worrying about how you're being perceived.
And as someone who's spent much of my adult life away from the place I grew up, I've come to appreciate how important those relationships can become.
Because home isn't necessarily just a geographical location.
Sometimes it's a collection of people who make you feel comfortable, accepted, and understood.
And when I think about gratitude, those are the things that stand out to me.
Not necessarily the enormous accomplishments or material things, although those are lovely too.
It's the friendships that have lasted through different chapters of my life. The people who have shown up when things were difficult. The conversations, experiences, and ordinary moments that have helped me feel connected.
Those are the things that make a life meaningful.
And honestly, they deserve a little more appreciation than we sometimes give them.
Maybe Thanksgiving Doesn't Need to Be So Complicated
So as Thanksgiving approaches, I'm not particularly interested in telling people how they're supposed to celebrate.
If you love the elaborate dinner, the decorations, and the entire production, fantastic.
If you hate the commercialization of holidays and want nothing to do with it, that's fine too.
But I think there's something worthwhile about taking an opportunity to reflect on the people and experiences that make our lives better.
Not because the calendar demands it.
Not because somebody on Instagram told us we should be grateful.
And certainly not because we need another thing to add to our self-improvement checklist.
Simply because life moves quickly, and it's easy to become so focused on what we're trying to accomplish that we overlook what we've already experienced.
Maybe gratitude doesn't need to be a complicated psychological exercise.
Maybe it's simply the decision to appreciate something while it's happening.
And maybe the most meaningful part of Thanksgiving isn't the food, the traditions, or whether you've created the perfect holiday experience.
Maybe it's the people you've found along the way.
Listen to HOT AIR: Are We Doing Thanksgiving All Wrong? (Part One)
In Part One of this two-part Thanksgiving special, I'm sharing my Canadian perspective on American holidays, why I think we should stop taking commercialized celebrations so seriously, the psychology of gratitude, and how moving from Toronto to Los Angeles helped me find my people.
It's a personal conversation about mindset, friendship, gratitude, and appreciating the life we're building without pretending everything is perfect.
And in Part Two, we're taking that conversation even deeper. We're exploring chosen family, the expectations surrounding biological relationships, and why the people we're related to aren't necessarily the only people who can make us feel loved and supported.
Listen to HOT AIR with Joshua Robert on your favorite podcast platform, follow @_hotairpod on Instagram and TikTok, and visit hotairwithjoshuarobert.com for merch, listener stories, and more.
Because sometimes the best things in our lives aren't the things we've planned.
They're the people we meet along the way.